next up previous
Next: Conclusions Up: No Title Previous: The myth of causality

Limitations

When scripts are convergent, this does not imply that they are non-disruptive. Convergence is a postcondition describing the resulting state of the network after the script completes. A convergent script can still make arbitrary changes while it executes, up to rebooting servers or even re-routing services to new servers. In this sense our definition is less stringent that that of Cfengine[2,3,4], which requires that a script avoid creating non-conforming equipment states while executing (which prevents it from rebooting servers).

This fact is the root of several limitations of the method. First, the method is inherently serial, because convergence and homogeneity are not otherwise guaranteed. Maelstrom, unlike make, cannot run scripts in parallel without presuming complete orthogonality of script domains of change. Future versions of Maelstrom may allow one to declare scripts as independent, to allow parallelism.

Perhaps the most severe hidden limit is the subtlety with which scripts must be developed in order to exhibit true and guaranteed homogeneity. The only reliable ways to assure this in practice are to use only scripts that administer non-overlapping domains and cannot behave inhomogeneously, or to force all scripts with overlapping domains to retrieve configuration information from a common and shared source.


next up previous
Next: Conclusions Up: No Title Previous: The myth of causality
Alva L. Couch
2001-10-02